By Sue Marsh
 
I know, the Welfare Reform Bill passed.  In a fizzle of shame, it gasped it's way through the Lords last night.
 
But we always knew it would, so I'm going to talk about pooh.

If you have Crohn's disease, you live in fear of one thing - the Gastro Bug.

My bowel is knackered already. I mean completely and utterly borked. It's had bits lopped off, bit's sliced and stitched, bit's stuck together, bits that just gave up and exploded fairly dramatically, bit's that turned into huge weeping abscesses and bits that sprung holes like a leaky bucket.

Thanks to the NHS, it's been repeatedly fixed, glued, joined, patched and soothed but I haven't got as much left as you lot and I have permanent gastro-enteritis.

Have you had food poisoning? I mean really? Have you spent all night on the toilet groaning, seriously thinking you're going to die? Did you pass out as the clammy sweat of nausea crept through every atom of your body? Did the pain feel like a red hot poker, stabbing through your guts and out through your spine? As the colour drained from your cheeks and you dripped with a shivering, cold, sweat? Did you pull all of your stomach muscles retching endless burning acid into the toilet bowl? Did you break a rib, the spasms of peristalsis racked your body so hard?

You couldn't believe it was possible to feel that ill and keep breathing could you? Come on really think about it! That dodgy curry after the rugby, the shellfish in Marbella, the gastric-flu that kept you in bed for a fortnight?

Well that happened to me when I was about ten and never stopped. Never. Not for a week. At first, I thought it could only be a matter of time - no body could repeatedly go through that endlessly, a horrific, grinding Groundhog Day and survive.

But you know, somehow, it can. I've never worked out how, but even when you want to go to bed and never wake up, when the pain is so bad you can't think, when you can't remember the last time you slept for more than an hour of two, you go on. I went through university and worked for 10 years through that. Every day.

28 years later, I'm slowing down a bit. My body is complaining, I have deficiencies of this and crumbling bits of that. My bones haven't developed properly and already have osteoporosis. My teeth have crumbled away from the steady coating of vomit acid. I can't walk very far or stand up for long or pick up my children - I'm really, really tired.

But some days, if I'm really lucky, once in a blue moon, I might be that fraudster on the water slide, pretending she's disabled. The "cheat" who dared to risk all of the above but still go to London for a day trip or cheer at the sidelines of my little boy's school football tournament. I'll be the one who defiantly hangs on to pleasure when it comes my way - it comes so rarely.

2 days ago, I caught a Gastric Bug. I've been lucky - it's been years, but the particularly snippy diarrhoea and vomiting bug that's putting healthy people in bed for two days has found me.

My bowel is their favourite playing ground of all. They will set up camps in my leaky bits, have parties in the pockets and loops that shouldn't be there. Last night, I broke my personal-best poohing record. My bowels exploded in agony 28 times!! 28!! I have no idea why I started counting, there was a point to it last night, but I've forgotten now. I may as well have cholera now, and I'm off to bed for a bit.

So why the graphic, uncomfortable, faecal, vulnerable post this morning?

Because the Welfare Reform Bill, 2010 passed last night and people like me just lost everything. Regular readers will know, I have been told I don't qualify for DLA and I almost certainly will lose Incapacity Benefit as nothing in the ESA descriptors would mean that I qualify for ESA. Even if I did I will lose it after a year as my husband earns more than £7,500 a year. I'll never qualify for the Long term Support Group because I will never be "completely incapable of any kind of work at all". Also, with a bit of luck, they'll never actually tell me I've only got six months to live, I'll just burst somewhere at some point. So that means I'll never qualify because I'll never be "terminally ill" (Though of course, I will be, potentially, every day.)

People with "moderate needs" like mine - I'll leave you to judge how moderate my disability sounds from the description I just gave above - will no longer qualify for any kind of Social Care. Nor will my children unless I get to the stage where I physically can't get them to school.

I won't qualify for the new PIP - my incontinence is not severe enough to qualify. I was incontinent 7 times last night, cleaned myself up, changed my own clothes. But I did it myself, which means my disability doesn't affect me, according to the new rules.

My husband won't get carer's allowance, we won't qualify for any of the things the Government say are exempting the disabled from the worst of this bill because look! They've de-classified me!! Evil genius isn't it? We won't be able to earn a little more before we lose support because guess what? I'm not disabled now, so I won't qualify for the "help disabled people are getting".

So if you haven't read my blog before, I hope all the talk of pooh didn't make you feel too uncomfortable. But I hope more than anything, that what we just did to compassion, dignity and the lives of sick and disabled people up and down the country makes you feel very uncomfortable indeed.

29th Feb, 2012. The Welfare Reform Bill, 2010, became an Act.

And everything changed.

 

Courtesy of Sue Marsh - http://diaryofabenefitscrounger.blogspot.com/

Comments  

 
# oldnat 2012-03-01 23:49
I've looked at Sue Marsh's blog quite often, She was also on TV, completely destroying the Tory/LD arguments for Welfare "Reform".

That they don't listen will surprise no one.
 
 
# Arbroath1320 2012-03-02 00:04
This is typical Tory slash and burn tactics. They have no comprehension of how ill people can be one day but fine, or "apparently" fine the next. All the "slash and burn" brigade see are pound signs.
 
 
# megsmaw 2012-03-02 00:24
I agree Arbroath 1320, my Aunt has Social Anxiety Disorder. She used to get benefits as this mental illness can have a crippling effect (fear of crowds, aggrophobia, general high anxiety). She was told by an unqualified dole numpty (the person who "assesses" the DLA/Incapacity benefit claimants) to change her meds and doseage. His questions for assessing her condition were also completely irrelevant to her. This guy was NOT a doctor, she had a written statement from her own GP explaining the severity and limitations of her condition. The dole's verdict? Get a job!

Just because you can't see an illness doesn't mean it's not there.



Signed the e-petition and shared on FB.
 
 
# SolTiger 2012-03-02 17:49
I suffer from Severe Social Anxiety myself so I know exactly the situation you are talking about.

When Income Support was replaced with ESA I had to go for a medical with a supposed doctor, basically she ran through a list of questions on a computer screen and sent me on my way.

I was then told I was fit for work and my benefits would be stopped. If it hasn't been for the support of my family and medical staff I see regularly I would have just curled into a ball as basically they were saying I was faking.

As it was I appealed the decision straight away, sent in some letters from both my Psychologist and Psychiatrist and got word back within a week they had changed their decision and I would not need a full appeal hearing, something which the thought of had sent my anxiety through the roof.

At the time I was of a mind to write an article for Newsnet about my experiences and it would have read not unlike this piece by Sue Marsh but after the appeal went through I just wanted to forget about the whole ordeal.

Recently it was suggested to me that I might also be entitled to low level Disability Living Allowance, I filled in the forms in great detail and once again got knocked back. Again I had the chance to appeal but due to a string of bad days and family having to deal with other upheaval I never did.

This was atleast partly because I didn't want to risk having that feeling of being told I'm faking it, lazy or things aren't really that bad. Something which is especially hurtful when you suffer from social anxiety and often wonder what others are thinking of you along with often unfair, overly critical views of yourself.

The support from my family has been amazing, especially my mother who basically pays my way in life at the moment. I am incredibly lucky that she had a good job and now a good pension to be able to have a house big enough for me to stay in and also cover the bills. She is not entitled to any money as she isn't a "carer" as I don't require round the clock assistance and also her pension probably puts her over an income limit for such support. Why would she be entitled to anything, she's only paid her taxes for over 40 years...

Even as I write this I have yet another "fill in this questionnaire or lose your benefits" form sitting beside me that I need to send back by the end of next week, looks like I'm going to have to dig up some motivation, put my anxiety aside to ask for help and get it sent in.

I'm getting that "curl into a ball and hope it all goes away" feeling again.
 
 
# Mad Jock McMad 2012-03-02 00:28
The classic case of the Tories knowing the cost of everything and the value of nothing.

The problem with the Tories and Libdem thinking about the 'chronically ill' is they think employers will just suck us up into jobs ... the problem is if you tell a potential employer you suffer from PTSD, Fibromyalgia, a TIA and cervical strain, you become aware of a metaphysical sucking of teeth and some how you never get the second interview. You then get a politically correct letter which may or may not mention your chronic illness (usually wishing you well in the future) and unfortunately you are over qualified for the job / we have promoted from within the company.

Do you know, if I were in the interviewer's shoes I would go the same way because I would not want to employ some one who could disappear sick for six months because of a manic depressive PTSD breakdown or falls asleep for a couple of hours during the working day when the fibromyalgia is playing up plus being prone to repetitive strain problems because of his knackered neck ...

That is the problem with chronic illness it not the day to day but the accumulative impact - I played a round of golf on Wednesday and paid for it by sleeping for 12 hours solid today to recover.
 
 
# snowthistle 2012-03-02 10:20
I remember back in the old days, when Thatcher decided to tighten up on disability benefit, my father was passed fit for work despite his rheumatoid arthritis. He had to be taken into hospital for a weeks bed rest after the assessment. He was declared unfit on appeal but he was a proud man and I remember only too well what the whole process did to him (and to the rest of the family).
The kind of indepth assessment that needs to be done in order to decide whether people are fit for work would be expensive to run and while it would make the system fairer (we all know there are some who abuse it) it would not save money. We can't have both.
 
 
# snowthistle 2012-03-02 00:30
Sue, I was about to say that your article was really moving and then thought that wasn't quite right.
Seriously though thanks for giving us a much clearer understanding.
 
 
# tartanfever 2012-03-02 10:06
This govt. has completely failed - they should go.

They should be removed from power. The only duty a govt has is to the welfare of our citizens - thats it, nothing else. When they start spending billions on wars, weapons and bankers they have clearly failed the vast majority of people who really need help.

It is that simple.
 
 
# Exile 2012-03-02 11:34
What a quaint idea, tf. I thought the duty of the UK government was to service the needs of the financial oligarchy centred in and around London. At least, that's what its been doing for decades/centuries/ever (delete as appropriate).
 
 
# clootie 2012-03-02 11:37
I'm at a loss to even begin to understand what this will mean to some people.

Is this a union dividend? It doesn't sound like the society most of us want?

I know it's simplistic but I cannot read an article like this without Trident / Bank bonus / illegal wars / Quantative easing etc all going through my head at the same time.

Beam me up Scotty!

Vote NO and you will be getting a lot more of this from ALL of the main Westminster parties.
 
 
# Fungus 2012-03-02 11:27
Quote:
what we just did to compassion, dignity and the lives of sick and disabled people up and down the country makes you feel very uncomfortable indeed.


It didn't make me uncomfortable...it made me blazing mad angry. But 'we' didn't do this, a wealthy and privileged minority who have never known what it is like to be helpless or poor or hungry did this.
When I was reading your piece I was reminded of the unattributable quote "A society is measured on how it treats it's weakest" but then Thatcher did say "There is no such thing as society" and that is at the heart of this. A political cadre of psychopaths turning their back on the most needy of society in order to feather their own nests.
The only crumb I can offer is that, at least in this country, it won't last much longer. When we regain our independence, and we shall, our riches won't be used to boost profits of money speculators or rent nuclear tipped missiles from the US or be wasted on feel-good projects for the SE of England. Our money will go towards making Scotland a just and equitable society for all of her citizens..rich or poor, healthy or disabled.
 
 
# Robabody 2012-03-02 15:00
Hear, hear Fungus and it's not the kind of society I want to live in either. Sue, great article and thank you for the enlightenment. Words at times are trite but please accept my best wishes for the future and the hope that help / cure may, one day, be forthcoming.
 
 
# bringiton 2012-03-02 11:57
Thank you Sue,living with a chronic health condition is difficult enough without having to worry about paying the bills as well.
The Tories and their friends the Nu Tories are pretending that "we are all in this together" and demonstrate this by having the tax man go after one or two high profile tax dodgers like Harry Redknapp and Rangers FC but the reality is of course that,as always with the Tories,it is the most vulnerable in our society that end up being hit hardest.
They get away with this by having the support of rabid media outlets who publish ficticious and hysterical stories about benefit fraud.
The amount of money lost in terms of benefit fraud is a drop in the ocean compared to that lost through tax evasion but it is much easier to hit benefits than it is to go after money which has found its way offshore.
The Tories,Nu Tories and Nu Labour are all more or less in support of this policy so we have a clear picture of where the UK is heading in terms of future social care.
This should be a wake up call for anyone in Scotland who views the current system of government as delivering social welfare in a fair and equitable manner.
We are heading down the road of no care unless you can afford to pay for it.
These are not values I suspect which are held by most Scots and once the penny drops about this legislation and more to follow in a similar vein independence will come to be viewed as the only alternative.
Hope things don't get too bad for you Sue.
 
 
# Macart 2012-03-02 13:04
A good article Sue and brings the point home. Having had some personal experience of home caring I can sympathise. Like bringiton above, hope things don't get too bad for you.
 
 
# Lucas 2012-03-02 14:24
In a properly organised society, Sue Marsh would be a Government advisor. I am nothing like as unwell as she is, but my M.E. is highly, but not continuously, debilitating. In consequence, I too am debarred from being to claim any benefits, and am denied access to services that the receipt of benefits would qualify me for. Forty years of continuous employment counts for nothing either. Labour introduced the new ESA system, and the Tory Gradgrinds enthusiasticall y support it. Neither party seems to have the first clue about the hardship and misery that they are causing.
 
 
# RandomScot 2012-03-02 15:34
Lucas

That doesn't sound right. "REPEATABILITY" is key, and, through gritted teeth, Lord Freud has grudgingly allowed that if a task is not repeatable then you answer "no" to "Can you do this?"
 
 
# RandomScot 2012-03-02 15:32
I occasionally communicate with Sue, she is a passionate believer in aLabour Party that in some measure is the architect of her woes.

She knows that, and she, and her co campaigners such as Kalyia Franklin are actually causing themselves mischiefs trying to drive home what is happening.

They, SpoonieDoc etc deserve support, even if they are in the "wrong party", because they are fighting a fight that needs to be won.

Otherwise it's US style insurance misery from here on in
 
 
# Arbroath1320 2012-03-02 16:12
Isn't it amazing. Here we have the blue nose Tories, and their best buddies the Lib/Dems, pushing this abhorrent bill through and yet at the same time we have this happening in Whitehall and government departments.

telegraph.co.uk/.../...

I have a piece of advice for Cameroon bar and his buddies. Clean up this mess before you attack the ill and infirm!
 
 
# Jenny2603 2012-03-02 22:08
This is a sad, shocking but not surprising article. When Labour decided to scrap Incapacity Benefit and replace it with ESA they were told repeatedly by numerous charities, law/advice centres and campaigners that situations like Sue's would arise. They were told their policy would fail the most vulnerable. Nevertheless they pressed on anxious to play to the Daily Mail crowd by being tough on 'scroungers'. That the Tories have embraced this 'tough' new medical and even aped Labour's dishonest claim about 'helping' people off benefits and into work is no surprise. They must have been delighted to arrive in office and find the Labour Party had already done their dirty work for them.

The terrifying thing is on a UK level there is no effective, elected opposition to this. Labour are as committed to the destruction of the welfare state as the Tories are. Sure they'll kick off over some trivial proposal but when push comes to shove they'll play along to appear reasonable to middle England. The Lib Dems are a joke and every bit as bad as the other two. I have often wondered who I would vote for if I lived in England and I am honestly stumped. There is no choice.

Both the press and politicians have massively overplayed the problem of benefit fraud. Rather than the nation being bled dry it is estimated that around £5.2billion is lost every year between fraud and DWP/Customer error. However this is dwarfed by the £16billion in benefits lying unclaimed each year.

Whilst only a fool would deny fraud exists, it is being cynically used a convenient smokescreen to dismantle the welfare state. No system is fraud proof but there is plenty the government could do to make life difficult for the fraudsters without turning their back on the numerous genuine cases.

If anyone thinks they are not affected by this because they're fit and healthy or in fairly secure work -think again. In my years as a Welfare Rights worker I met numerous people who genuinely thought the fact they've worked all their lives and paid into the system counted in their favour. In the eyes of ATOS and the DWP it doesn't matter a bit. As far as they are concerned if you're claiming you're dishonest.

If your circumstances mean that you would have to claim benefits if you fell ill or were out of work then you'll be treated every bit as badly as Sue and millions like her. These aren't just 'anti-scrounger' laws. They're anti-you.

Finally when I started out in Welfare Rights nearly nine years ago, with the exception of homeless clients I'd be hard pushed to name a single client who regularly relied on sources of free/cheap food from charities and soup kitchens. In the last two years it has been getting more commonplace. That people are having to choose between food and power cards in what is meant to be a civilised country is a measure of how bad things have got and it's going to get even worse. The crowning insult to so many people living in real grinding poverty and struggling with ill health is that the right wing media and our equally right wing Westmonster politicians would have us believe those on benefits are living in luxury on the back of the tax payer. We're all in it together!
 
 
# expat67 2012-03-05 02:07
What an indictment of the present state of the ideals of the once admired welfare state!
 
 
# Pictavia 2012-03-03 11:45
What is either Liberal or Democratic about these people. Their collaboration with the Tories enables such attacks on the sick and vulnerable

Danny Alexander
Inverness, Nairn, Badenoch and Strathspey
Michael Moore
Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk
Sir Menzies Campbell
North East Fife
Alistair Carmichael
Orkney and ShetlandDeputy Chief Whip
Charles Kennedy
Ross, Skye and Lochaber
Jo Swinson
East Dunbartonshire
Malcolm Bruce
Gordon
Mike Crockart
Edinburgh West
Alan Reid
Argyll and Bute
Sir Robert Smith
West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
John Thurso
Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross

Read the above article then hang your heads in shame
 
 
# cokynutjoe 2012-03-05 22:40
Meanwhile, back in the real world, a cash strapped Duke of Sutherland gets a cool £40 million for a painting.
 

You must be logged-in in order to post a comment.

Donate to Newsnet Scotland

Banner

Latest Comments