By a Newsnet reporter
Labour health spokesperson Jackie Baillie has been accused of making claims against an NHS hospital for which there was no proof.
Speaking at the Labour conference yesterday, Ms Baillie claimed that in one Greater Glasgow and Clyde hospital patients had been forced to “share blankets” because of cuts.
However Ms Baillie’s claims were immediately called into question by a spokesman for the area’s Health Board who claimed they were untrue and that the claim had been proven false weeks ago.
A spokeswoman for Greater Glasgow and Clyde Health Board said: “This matter was raised with us a few weeks ago and we were able to provide proof that there was no truth in this claim.”
She added: “Extra blankets are available in all our hospitals, as and when patients need them.”
Jackie Baillie had claimed that a number of constituents had contacted her with concerns about the Royal Alexandria Hospital in Paisley.
Speaking at her party’s conference, Ms Baillie said: “In one hospital, in Greater Glasgow and Clyde, patients are even having to share blankets because of the cuts.
“The truth is, the fault lies with the SNP because even in times of plenty, they have underfunded the NHS.”
A spokeperson for Health Secretary Nicola Sturgeon accused the Labour MSP of misleading people and said;
“Jackie Baillie should be ashamed of herself for talking down Scotland’s health service in this way and misleading people – the health board provided proof weeks ago that there is no truth in this claim.”
This is the second time in two months that claims by the same Labour MSP have been called into question.
On January 3rd Ms Baillie faced calls to apologise after a press release, issued by her and attacking the SNP’s record on hospital infections, was exposed as being out of date and used data from a time when Labour were in office.
The press release issued by Ms Baillie claimed that official figures showed that Scotland was now the “superbug capital of Europe”.
Ms Baillie claimed that research from the Scottish Parliament Information Centre showed that Scotland had the highest rate of bugs in Europe, hitting 9.5 per cent.
Speaking on BBC Scotland, Ms Baillie said: “Being the superbug capital of Europe is an accolade no country wants.
“These figures show that, despite recent progress, the SNP government still has a long way to go in the battle against healthcare-associated infections.”
However, it emerged that the data had been collated in 2005/6, at a time when Labour were in power at Holyrood.
Official statistics released in October last year showed that cases of MRSA and MSSA were in fact at their lowest level since records began.
Why cant she be both brusque?
Ms Baillie is a proven liar – who is also apparently unable to research any of the fantasist claims she has made recently; Or perhaps I’m being kind to imply she is only guilty of not bothering to check – the alternative can only be that she just goes ahead and knowingly lies.
Which is it Ms Baillie, Lazy or Liar?
Ms Baillie is a proven liar – who is also apparently unable to research any of the fantasist claims she has made recently; Or perhaps I’m being kind to imply she is only guilty of not bothering to check – the alternative can only be that she just goes ahead and knowingly lies.
Which is it Ms Baillie, Lazy or Liar?
This is true Oldnat…
Yet it could be worse up here:
guardian.co.uk/…/…
Revealed: government plans for police privatisation
West Midlands and Surrey police offer £1.5bn contract under which private firms may investigate crime and detain suspects
So how would you hold a government to account if they didnt provide any of your services???
Maybe she was stealing them from other patients’ beds… 😉
Why do you assume that the SNP MSPs are silent on this issue? Baillie’s absurd comments were only made yesterday.
It’s also the case that sometimes political points are so transparently stupid that for a “collective howl” from SNP MSPs would give such rubbish more attention than it deserves.
Oh good…so the MSPs will all stay quiet and let our parliament be mislead because there are sensible refutations in the article?
You can howl sensibly.
Hands up, I’m an ignoramus! We have a parliament, we have a majority SNP government and we have had two labour ladies (Lamont and Baillie) spouting distortions. In the first instance, about a fictitious version of a rape and in the second (from a serial NHS guff spouter) about insufficient blankets. Now this is where my ignorance cuts in, why, when one has clearly mislead parliament and the other is misleading the public, is there no challenge in the parliament? Where are the SNP MSP’s when this tosh is shown to be just that? Where is the presiding officer when the parliament is being misdirected? Why do we not see them howling? Answers please (and don’t bother to blame the MSM they are beyond the pale already)?
Look at the NHS in the rest of the UK and be afraid.In reality,it shouldn’t even be called the NHS down there anymore.
I work for the NHS and I can assure Jackie Bailey that anyone making patients share blankets in an NHS hospital would be subject to a disciplinary procedure that would lead to not only dismissal from that job, but almost certainly the removal of the nurses ‘pin’ without which they would be unable to work as a nurse anywhere in the UK.
This isn’t an issue of patient comfort, it is an issue of ‘cross infection’
Just to give people an indication of how serious this is, I recently attended a mandatory training day: ‘Infection Control’ A nurse was asked to wash her hands and then her she put her hands under an ultra violet light which showed any spots that she had missed. we all then had to do the same. I have been ‘watched’ on a number of occasions over the past years washing my hands and the results have been recorded !
I work in mental health !!!
I work in England but I can assure everyone that the same level of concern about ‘cross infection’ is shared throughout the NHS.
It genuinely is a matter of life and death and the idea that any nurse would ask patients to share blankets in a medical ward is simply a lie and Jackie Bailey is indulging in the scaremongering that is now the labour parties politics of choice.
In other words, she is a disgusting liar !
Slightly off subject but I just watched the “living dead”, as far as the electorate are concerned, Moore, on the Andrew Marr Show, failing to answer one question directly, and visibly spluttering when asked who would be leading the anti-independence campaign. I think he suggested Darling, so who knows. Can anyone confirm that A.S will be appearing on Sunday Politics today?
I thought that Isabel Fraser was spot on with Clegg this morning.
The funniest part for me (if my memory serves me right) was when he was going on about opposing two questions on the Ballot paper when he said ‘what do you do if every one answers yes, yes’
No wonder the Lib Dums are finished politically and will find this out at the next election.
Scottish lawyer Paul McBride QC, who two men are accused of conspiring to murder, dies in Pakistan