Newsnet Main Articles
By Martin Kelly
Secretary of State for Scotland Michael Moore has been ridiculed after demanding to know details of taxes in an independent Scotland.
SNP MP Stewart Hosie pointed out that the Lib Dem MP was calling for answers on tax for an independent Scotland when he didn’t even know what the tax policy of his own UK coalition was going to be next week.
Mr Hosie was responding after comments by Mr Moore at a conference for the Scottish Council for Development & Industry in St Andrews where the UK Minister had called for “clarity” over taxes “in an independent Scotland”.
Describing the demands as a “blunder” the Scottish National Party’s Westminster Treasury Spokesperson said:
“This is a blunder by Michael Moore – he doesn’t even know what UK tax rates will be next Wednesday, so his latest contribution to the Tory-led anti-independence campaign is singularly ill-timed.
“The Tory Chancellor George Osborne is widely reported to be scrapping the top rate of income tax for the richest people in next week’s Budget – a move which the Lib Dem Treasury Chief Secretary has described as ‘in cloud cuckoo land’!”
Mr Hosie’s claim was a reference to an interview given by Mr Moore’s Lib Dem colleague, Treasury Chief Danny Alexander, who said last July when asked if there were plans to scrap the 50p top rate of tax:
“The idea that we’re going to somehow shift our focus to the wealthiest in the country at a time when everyone’s under pressure is just in cloud cuckoo land,”
Mr Hosie contrasted Mr Moore’s pre-budget remarks with those of the First Minister Alex Salmond, who has urged the UK Government to “to unlock access to finance for small and medium sized businesses across Scotland” after it emerged that the much vaunted ‘Project Merlin’ had lent less than 5% to Scottish businesses.
Project Merlin is a scheme set up by the coalition involving the four major high street banks that is supposed to see a curb in banker bonuses and prioritise lending to small and medium sized businesses.
Mr Hosie added:
“It’s a pity that Mr Moore was unable to address this vital issue, which is the clear responsibility of the Tory/Lib Dem coalition.
“We know from the Government Expenditure & Revenue Scotland figures (GERS) that, last year alone, Scotland was in a stronger financial position than the UK as a whole to the tune of nearly £2.7 billion – or £510 for every man, woman and child in Scotland.
“And we also know that the Scottish Government has modelled the benefits of having a 20 per cent rate of corporation tax in Scotland, compared to the UK’s planned rate of 23 per cent – which would create 27,000 more jobs in the Scottish economy in the medium to longer term.
“Compared to the leaden, negative arguments of the Tories and other anti-independence parties, this is the information and these are the arguments that can and will win the referendum in autumn 2014.”
Small countries have the option of introducing flat tax.
Another SDA policy!
What’s a flat tax
In essence it is a flat (single) rate of income tax which everyone pays on every penny they earn. There are no allowances or deductions, and no changes in tax rates as earnings increase. If, say, the flat rate was 15%, a person earning 10k per annum would pay 1500 in tax, and a person earning 100k per annum would pay 15k in tax. It’s simple, and everyone knows exactly what their tax liability is.
But what damage these nonentities are doing against Scotland. Alexander and Moore have to be the worst examples of lap-dog governor; over-promoted, over-hyped, stupidly and wantonly reckless about Scotland and interested only in number-one. Shocking, truly despicable people.
Agree to certain extent, but the people of Scotland has the Libdem liars sussed which will be proved very shortly. This guy is not convincing anyone..quite the opposite I reckon that the majority of listeners just ignore the straw man’s comments.
Dundonian West
” —and people still ask,”Why does the UK (Westminster) want to hold on to Scotland?”
TRUTH WILL OUT—ALWAYS. !
BBC ALBA: Truth, Lies, Oil and Scotland
Part 1 – www.youtube.com/…/
Part 2 – www.youtube.com/…/
Part 3 – www.youtube.com/…/
Part 4 – www.youtube.com/…/
Part 5 – www.youtube.com/…/
Part 6 – www.youtube.com/…/]
Part 7 – www.youtube.com/…/
THANKS A MILLION for the youtube video oil links above.
Ought to be shoved through every letterbox in Scotland,but I’m sure there’s a law against that sort of thing.
Straight into my Favourites—I may need them again sometime
“Then shall the eyes of the blind be opened”.
Handel’s Messiah Part 1.Alto.
A pretty decent effort Alec. The friendly tone is the way to do it. However, I fear your friend won’t actually be open to persuasion using pesky things like facts. Many of those who wish to stay in the union, attempt to make a case with their own ‘facts’, when in reality, their loyalty is actually on an emotional basis. There’s enough in Neil’s letter to suggest to me that that is the case here too.
Indeed. I think I commented on how ScotNats get criticised for Using the past as a reason for independence but BritNats do it all the time.
I wrote it, not only for his attention, but also for the attention of all of those who would see it when I linked it on his FB page. I don’t have the articulation and finesse that some of NNS writers do (Hazel being one example!) but figured it was worth a shot. Thanks 🙂