Newsnet Main Articles

  By Anne-Marie O’Donnell
There is a “growing consensus” in UK politics that has allowed those battling poverty to be stigmatised as “skivers” and “scroungers”, an expert has warned.
In a submission to the Scottish Parliament’s Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee, Morag Gillespie of the Scottish Poverty Information Unit at Glasgow Caledonian University said the emerging trend within UK politics was along “neo-liberal lines” but added that Scotland is in a position to set itself apart from the wider narrative.

The submission came on the same day as a report from Oxfam revealed that the Westminster coalition’s welfare cuts have pushed 1.75 million of the poorest households in the UK into further poverty, leaving families struggling to meet the most basic costs.

“There is a growing consensus in UK politics along neo-liberal lines in which poverty has been individualised and stigmatised and people relying on social security benefits are cast as ‘skivers’ and ‘scroungers’, responsible themselves for the situations they find themselves in,” Ms Gillespie wrote.  “Debate is more about the detail of managing poverty than how to reduce or eradicate either poverty or the yawning gulf in inequalities of income and wealth.

“A country where the majority of people defined as poor live in households where someone works is testament to a system that isn’t working.  Scotland has the opportunity to do much more than just manage the existing system more efficiently.”

She added: “There is an opportunity to start afresh and develop a vision for a poverty-free Scotland that includes (but is not limited to) a system of Social Security that sets out  to: diminish and remove the fear and insecurity many face today; prevent poverty  happening wherever possible rather than stigmatising those who become poor; and  reflect the range of contributions that people make to society including, for example  the caring roles undertaken – predominantly by women – that are currently undervalued but form a crucial part of the glue that holds a good society together.”

The Oxfam report, in conjunction with the New Policy Institute, found that 300,000 household have experienced cuts to housing benefit following the introduction of coalition policies like the Bedroom Tax, 920,000 have seen a cut in council tax benefit and 480,000 households have received cuts to both.

The report also follows recent figures from the Trussell Trust which showed nearly one million people have now been forced to rely on a foodbank to avoid starving, many of them children.  Just days after the figures were released, it emerged that Prime Minister David Cameron’s constituency office called out police to deal with church leaders the Bishop of Oxford and Reverend Keith Hebden after they tried to deliver an open letter on food poverty.

Joan McAlpine MSP, a member of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee, said Ms Gillespie’s submission showed an urgent need for Scotland to take matters into its own hands.

“We must grasp the opportunity to truly tackle inequality – as Morag Gillespie points out in her submission the need to take action is more vital than ever with figures showing Westminster’s welfare cuts could push up to 100,000 more children in Scotland into poverty by 2020,” she said.

“Vulnerable children in Scotland simply cannot afford to be subject to Westminster’s austerity agenda any more.  The opportunity to tackle poverty shows exactly why Scotland can, should and must be independent.”

Ms Gillespie’s submission outlined a range of policy areas in which she argued fairness and simplicity was needed, such as social security and taxation, and said lessons could be learned by exploring Nordic systems already proving effective at reducing poverty.


2014-04-23 11:12

It is not the case that people actually “become poor”, because it is quite common for people to be born into poverty, which goes back generations. They are not property owners, the have low level jobs, if any at all and have few prospects.
We need a whole mind shift in how we manage and develop our society to be much more equal for all and will require the Scottish government to enable communities to work on how that can shaped for themselves, and not making decisions only from the top down. Teachers and those working in communities do a brilliant job, but the system has to change to make the huge step to creating a more forward looking and modern thinking society.

The tories have always demonised the poor and will continue to do so,they thrive on divide and rule, and the sad thing is many people fall for that every time. A YES vote will be the only way to be rid of that backward mentality once and for all.
2014-04-23 22:45

Hetty –another factor is low aspiration and the labour party have traded on that generations
2014-04-25 04:00

The issue has never been low aspiration, fittie, the issue has been the destruction of aspiration by successive governments who have deliberately robbed people of a decent education or a chance to work and gain skills and experience.

Scotland suffers under a London government which seeks to centralise everything in the southeast… as far from Scotland as possible. Many leave Scotland to strive elsewhere, while those less fortunate or brave are left in Scotland with their hearts broken and trapped in debt and the benefits culture.

it wasn’t what they wanted when they left school, it wasn’t what they believed their lives would amount to… nonetheless we have to recognise where the fault lies and seek to rectify it. Blaming the victims is the act of an arrogant ass who was one of the few lucky ones.

I have left Scotland only recently… for precisely the same reasons.

You must be logged-in in order to post a comment.